Blacks in Power Don't Empower Blacks

Between 1970 and 2012, the number of black elected officials rose from fewer than 1,500 to more than 10,000. How has this affected the black community? Jason Riley of The Manhattan Institute answers the question in this video.

Blacks in Power Don't Empower Blacks

Since 1965, the number of black elected officials has exploded. Between 1970 and 2012, it grew from fewer than 1,500 to more than 10,000. And, oh, yes—a black man was elected president. Twice.

Conventional wisdom would suggest that all these political gains would lead to economic gains. But that has not proven to be the case. In fact, during an era of growing black political influence, blacks as a group progressed at a slower rate than whites, and the black poor actually lost ground.

Why was the conventional wisdom wrong?

Because it was based on the incorrect assumption that politics was the pathway to black progress. Only black politicians, so the thinking went, could properly understand and address the challenges facing black Americans.

It wasn’t stable families, hard work, or education that would lift blacks into the middle class; it was more black city councilmen, congressmen and senators.

But the evidence, even according to liberal social scientists like Gary Orfield, “indicates that there may be little relationship between the success of . . . black leaders and the opportunities of typical black families.”

So, while black politicians, from Tom Bradley and Marion Barry to Maxine Waters and John Conyers, achieved considerable personal success, their constituents did not.

Yet this calculus—political success is a pre-requisite to a better life—remains progressive orthodoxy today.

When Michael Brown was shot dead after assaulting a police officer in Ferguson, Missouri, in 2014, much was made over the racial composition of the police department and city leaders.
But if black representation among law enforcement and city officials is so critically important, how do you explain the rioting in Baltimore the following year after a black suspect there died in police custody? At the time, 40 percent of Baltimore’s police officers were black. The Baltimore police commissioner was also black, along with the mayor and a majority of the city council.

What can be said of Baltimore is also true of Cleveland, Detroit, Philadelphia, Atlanta, New Orleans and Washington, D.C., where black mayors and police chiefs and city councilmen and school superintendents have been in office for decades.

But to what end?

As I document in my book, False Black Power?, when blacks had little political power, they nevertheless made significant economic progress. In the 1940s and ’50s, black labor-participation rates exceeded those of whites, black incomes grew much faster than white incomes, and the black poverty rate fell by 40 percentage points. Between 1940 and 1970—that is, during the Jim Crow era, with its racist laws— and before any affirmative action, the number of blacks in middle-class professions quadrupled. In other words, racial gaps were steadily narrowing without any special treatment for blacks.

And then came the War on Poverty in the mid-sixties.

This was supposed to close the gap once and for all. Yet, despite billions of dollars of government assistance in the form of welfare payments, housing projects and enforced hiring programs like affirmative action, black poverty rates remained unchanged relative to white poverty rates.

In fact, a strong case can be made that to the extent that a social program, however well-meaning, interferes with a group's self-development, it does more harm than good. Government policies that discourage marriage and undermine the work ethic—open-ended welfare benefits, for example—help keep poor people poor.

With thanks to Prager U for the use of their film. We do not own the rights to any of this film. This film is being used for teaching and educational purposes only. No copyright infringement intended.

Black Matters: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCWp2...

Blacks in Power Don't Empower Blacks leadership quotes
1 Likes	1 Dislikes
15 views views	37 followers
People & Blogs	Upload TimePublished on 31 May 2019

Related keywords

video phone beyonce mp3,conservative synonym,answer แปลว่าอะไร,videos for cats,government jobs,leadership principles amazon,leadership styles,police simulator patrol duty descargar,video phone letra,answer the phone แปลว่า,family leisure,free ringtones,freedom mortgage,video doorbell,power of attorney,community manager cordoba,police simulator patrol duty,president obama,president of france,liberal meaning,family ties,government definition,police car,sharing amazon prime,sharingan eyes,video phone é a continuação de telephone,blackmart,video player,politics quiz,camera iphone x apk,answer the following questions,african american history,politics of dancing,political animals online latino,african american actresses,politics definition,sharing is caring,economic globalization,black clover,don't starve together,police academy,middle class definition,democratic primary,camera iphone 7 vs iphone 8,video editing app,free music,middle class filipino,video phone ft lady gaga,leadership quarterly,government grants,powerdirector,politics and the english language,african american vernacular english,middle class people,family halloween costumes,political issues,powerpoint to pdf,african american history museum,opportunity cost 意味,video phone call,african american museum dc,don't stop me now,power factor,black panther,conservative definition,upload resume to linkedin,sharing wifi password,opportunity 例文,leaders brettspiel,presidents cup,sharing wifi iphone,political revolution,economic calendar,conservative beliefs,american standard,police stories,conservative podcasts,opportunity 略,upload music to spotify,middle class in tagalog,liberal arts,economic systems,presidential election,police story,americans in the tour de france,political map of ecuador,democratic debate,democratic primary debates,sharing network 5k,powerpoint,upload soundcloud,power iso,americans killed in dominican republic,presidents day 2020,powerpoint templates,leadership definition,political compass,polycel,opportunity occasion,family reunion,free movies,camera phone x apk,sharingan contacts,opportunity 複数形,video games,opportunity portal,democratic presidential candidates,middle class jobs,liberally,upload to instagram from pc,conservative news sites,blackberry fruit,leaders academy,don't tread on me,black shark 2,government mule,don't starve,democratic,camera phone x,video phone tradução,democratic polls,community manager carrera,middle class status,don't look now,answer the questions แปลว่า,african american hairstyles,video phone lady gaga,don't bring me down,don't lyrics,liberal ks,blackberry phone,question letra,political animals capitulo 1 sub español,african american art,blackberry,community manager que hace,political animals online subtitulado,economic recession,free credit score,camera iphone 8 plus apk,leadership hoch 3,family matters,americans for prosperity,african american movies,answers,family guy,middle class meaning,power vpn,answers แปลว่า,community serie,videoder,videographer,sharing shelf,opportunity cost,upload speed,family quotes,politics watchdog,political speech,camera iphone 7 plus,president salary,americans cast,video camera,community manager utn,community manager,question words,don't even think,americansafetycouncil,community shield,policentrismo,police ice,uploadvr,police squad,government center,question tags explanation,community manager argentina,upload speed test,video phone beyonce,conservative news,government holidays,sharingan naruto,political map,economic opportunity act,opportunity to,upload download speed,political animals,america's best,answer these questions,upload youtube,upload to google drive,freeform,african american movies 2019,answer ตัวย่อ,camera iphone xr vs xs,videogamedunkey,opportunity chance,sharing economy,sharing kindle books,sharing community yonkers,free vpn,leadership training,camera iphone x,politics for dummies,video editing software free,free fonts,video phone screen,community manager empleo,government per diem rates,upload pictures,government bonds,questione di karma,video phone wikipedia,political news,freecell,video phone gaga,video phone beyonce lyrics,government shutdown 2019,freebirds,economics definition,government assistance,middle class meaning in tagalog,video killed the radio star,upload pdf to kindle,leadership coaching,video game stores,poweramp,government cheese,presidents of the us,opportunity loss,liberal news sites,upload studio,freestyle libre,family mobile,sharing network,conservative republican,camera iphone 8,upload image,answer the questions,http://americanspirit.com,power division,camera iphone 7,camera iphone 6,leadership,question mark,liberal arts majors,camera phone 2019,middle class lifestyle,polisémico,sharing google calendar,middle class philippines,politics podcast,economics is the study of,upload video,questions en ingles,political refugee,liberal democrats,leaders eat last,video phone beyonce lady gaga,opportunity of,question traduccion,don't knock twice,community manager freelance,policeman,black mirror season 5,middle class in the philippines 2018,middle class population philippines,video phone commax,americans abroad,conservative talk radio,middle class examples,don't let go,family movies,don't fear the reaper,politically correct,video phone number,questions in english,african american actors,democratic front runners,middle class philippines salary,community manager curso,liberal arts degree jobs,sharing community,african american last names,president of brazil,leadership management,government shutdown,community manager siglo 21,politicspa,president trump twitter,family feud,black rose,answering machine,don't speak,conservative twins,conservative states,politics and war,community manager rosario,question tags exercises,president trump,conservative review,economic powers act of 1977,americans for the arts,community college,upload video to youtube,president macron,question words exercises,community manager trabajo,community online,african american names,freep,video phone extended remix,sharingbox,democratic candidates,video editor,blacklist,middle class family means,power bi,political compass test,leadership 4.0,politics and prose events,conservative websites,camera iphone,camera phone comparison,sharing is caring meme,economics major,presidents in order,app video iphone,black mamba,camera iphone 8 plus,camera iphone xr,economical,answergarden,blackpink,america's got talent,african american museum,don't tell mama,african american boy names,political economics,don't blink,questions without auxiliaries,americans missing in barbados,free people,democratic debate date,sharing outlook calendar,don't let me down,politics can be defined as,community day,black hole,economic profit,answer sheet,power rangers ninja steel,community management,video phone beyonce letra,government student loans,government rate setting,democratic national committee,don't rain on my parade,question profesional,black wallpaper,african american braids,power movie,opportunity chance 違い,family dollar near me,middle class income,economic policy institute,power rangers super ninja steel,power bank,video phone lyrics,answer sheet pdf,opportunity synonym,americans abroad soccer,leaders club,don't worry be happy,video star,conservative celebrities,president of india,americans dying in dr,liberal studies,free games,question pro,presidente beer,middle class family,liberal synonym,african american culture,political communication,power rangers dino charge,community manager curso gratis,leadership deutsch,poweramp full version unlocker,opportunity 発音,liberal kansas,answered,video converter,community manager uba,video maker,black man,americans with disabilities act,politics of love,video phone feat lady gaga,president nixon,video editing software,family dollar,questionable content,opportunity identifier,answer sheet toeic pdf,family search,middle class family in tagalog,free credit report,politics is,camera iphone x vs xr,video to gif,middle class house,camera phone ranking,free robux,question tags,question tags exercises pdf,upload to imgur,liberal arts colleges,presidential candidates,polisemia,camera phone x - os 12 camera apk,government contracts,economic collapse,presidents of the united states,question formation,economics degree,family guy cast,don't stop believin,camera iphone apk,political animals online,african american wigs,government travel card,free dating sites,democratic debate schedule 2019,opportunity for,free stock photos,opportunity 歌詞,politics synonym,politics and prose,democratic debate lineup,upload photos to icloud,questioning,economic growth,question revista,middle class synonym,video downloader,upload photo,liberal arts degree,power bank price in bd,government phones,political irish,economic times,family video,politics today,democratic socialism,policentrico,police simulator patrol duty requisitos,black background,economic sanctions,americans traveling to cuba,opportunity only knocks once,government auctions,answer true or false แปลว่า,americans for tax reform,presidential debate,policenauts,policella,blackberry z10,politics1,democratic debates 2019,policell,economic development,americans with disabilities act of 1990,free online games,answer อ่านว่า,free movies online,liberal democrats uk,answering,family fare,liberal arts college rankings,americanstrategic,leadership vs management,government agencies,power supply,conservative commentators,conservative democrat,family fun center,family reunion cast,family farm and home,liberal arts and sciences,americans dead in dominican republic,democratic nominee polls,black mirror,conservative party,don't breathe,liberal definition,power rangers,political science,political cartoon definition,democratic republic of congo,economic indicators,conservative actors,politics news,answer for heaven,democratic underground,african american girl names,question carta de colores,democratic debates schedule,policemento,black magic,black widow,upload file,conservative meaning,presidential polls,liberality,opportunity 語源,family tree,politics and prose bookstore,african american flag,leadership 2020,leadership principles,democratic nominees,government surplus,economic news,conservative search engine,don't stop believin lyrics,police officer,answer bts,opportunity 読み方 カタカナ,liberal arts definition,president carter,sharingan,sharingan tattoo,conservative colleges,video to mp3,leadership skills,liberal democracy,politics shoes,democratic candidates 2020,african american population,